[spacer height=”20px”]
Bob Colling Of Wrestling Recaps
From 1994 to 1998, World Championship Wrestling relied on wrestlers who, for the most part, made a name for themselves in the competitive promotion, the World Wrestling Federation. They signed Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage during the year of 1994 and the signings of Kevin Nash (Diesel) and Scott Hall (Razor Ramon) in 1996 propelled WCW to never before seen popularity.
Riding the wave of the New World Order, which all four of the aforementioned men were a part of at one point or another, WCW was making money hand over fist. By late 1997, WCW signed Bret Hart and looked to be untouchable.
That was until Steve Austin was inserted into the main event scene of the WWF, and the company that had seemingly been left for dead two years earlier was striving, while WCW was slowly but surely dying off.
That death of WCW was rapidly approaching as they couldn’t stop themselves from going back to the same old acts while WWF continued to reinvent itself.
By the summer of 1999, a new faction in WCW was developed and consisted of some of the companies best in-ring wrestlers. The group consisted of four men who had a past in Extreme Championship Wrestling, but had been held back in WCW. They wanted to be in the spot that guys like Hogan, Savage, Nash, Hall and Ric Flair had kept for over a decade.
The group I’m referring to was named ‘Revolution’ and consisted of Shane Douglas as the leader, along with Chris Benoit, Perry Saturn, and Dean Malenko rounding out the quartet.
Shane Douglas was very successful in ECW having won the ECW World Championship on four occasions and the ECW Television Championship on another two other occasions. He had also formed the original triple threat with Chris Benoit and Dean Malenko in the land of extreme. During his run with the Philadelphia based company, Douglas was given the nickname of being “The Franchise.
Shane left ECW one other time to jump ship to the WWF in mid 1995 where he was given the infamous character Dean Douglas. He wouldn’t even last a year before jumping back to ECW to continue his memorable run with the company. He stayed there until early 1999 when he signed with WCW.
Perry Saturn found success in ECW as part of the Eliminators with the late John Kronus. The team would win the ECW World Tag Team Championships on three different occasions. He jumped to WCW in 1997 and his popularity really showed in late 1998 while feuding with Raven. The peak of his popularity came in early 1999 when he was in a feud with Chris Jericho and ended up wearing a dress after a loss at Souled Out in January.
Dean Malenko won the ECW Television Championship on two occasions and the ECW World Tag Team Championship once during his time with the company. He also had a memorable series of matches with Eddie Guerrero. Those matches got both men signed to WCW where Malenko would win the WCW Cruiserweight Championship four times, WCW United States Championship one time and the WCW World Tag Team Championships one time with Benoit.
Malenko was always recognized as being a great wrestler and his feud with Jericho in the spring of 1998 catapulted Malenko as a babyface. However, by 1999 Malenko was again lost in the shuffle.
After breaking in for Stu Hart’s Stampede Wrestling in Calgary, Alberta, Canada, Chris Benoit made his name in Japan and had minor championship success with ECW winning the tag titles on one occasion. It didn’t take long for the WCW fan base to get behind Benoit as he had memorable feuds with Kevin Sullivan and Booker T from 1996 to 1998. By 1998, many fans were getting frustrated that Benoit had not won a championship in the company. While he would actually win the WCW Television Championship twice in 1998, they went virtually unrecognized as they happened on house shows.
Along with Malenko, Benoit finally won WCW gold and had it recognized on television when they won the WCW World Tag Team Championships at Uncensored. The reign didn’t even last a month, though. By the summer of 1999, all four men were lost in the shuffle at WCW.
After Saturn, Benoit and Malenko lost a six man tag match to Flair, DDP and Kanyon on the 7/29 Thunder, Douglas came out and officially formed the Revolution. He made it clear that they were sick of being overlooked for the old timers that WCW had relied on for quite some time.
At the time, this was exactly what WCW needed to do. In order to combat the WWF, they needed to focus on creating their own, younger stars, much like WWF had done after being raided by WCW numerous times over the years. A foundation of Douglas, Benoit, Malenko and Saturn would be a good start.
Unfortunately, WCW was never quite committed to the idea. Sure, Benoit won the WCW United States Championship on the August 9th over the undeserving David Flair and the Revolution won their pay-per-view matches at Road Wild where Benoit retained over Page and the other members beat the West Texas Rednecks but it was all downhill from there.
At the September PPV ‘Fall Brawl’, Benoit lost the WCW United States Championship to Sid Vicious, who was preparing for a feud against Goldberg and really had no reason to be champion since the feud had more than enough drawing power without a title. Even more surprising, the Revolution lost their other two matches on the card. Dean Malenko and Shane Douglas lost to career mid-carders Hugh Morrus and Brian Knobs. Perry Saturn failed to win the WCW Television Championship from Rick Steiner. I should note, Benoit would win the TV Championship from Rick Steiner on the following Nitro, only to lose it back at Halloween Havoc.
Over the course of the next several months, the group would actually disband with Benoit leaving and becoming a babyface. Douglas, Saturn and Malenko would feud with the Filthy Animals and have an Un-American gimmick, even though the entire group was actually from the United States.
Benoit would get his greatest success while not in the group when he beat Sid Vicious at Souled Out in January of 2000 to win the vacant WCW World Heavyweight Championship, but he left the company along with Saturn, Malenko and non-Revolution member Eddie Guerrero later that same week.
A stable that was to have changed the landscape of WCW lasted all of two and a half months before splitting up. But, looking back… were they even believable as main eventers?
Sure, Chris Benoit was, without question, a sure fire main event guy and the matches he had with Bret Hart proved that. The same goes with matches with Flair and Sting. I don’t recall Benoit wrestling Hogan, but even if he had, he wouldn’t have likely been able to do the moves or work the style that helped make him popular to begin with.
But, would a guy like Dean Malenko be believable? He made a career of having outstanding matches with guys his size like Rey, Juventud and Eddie. Would a Malenko vs. Hogan or Malenko vs. Sting bring out thousands of people? I don’t see it happening.
What about Perry Saturn and Shane Douglas? Shane was a main event caliber wrestler in his own mind, a great talker, but honestly can you think of a memorable match he was involved in? It takes me a minute to think of a good match that doesn’t involve Ricky Steamboat as his tag team partner.
Saturn never screamed main event material to me, either. At most, he would have been a great WCW United States Champion but anything more than that just wouldn’t be realistic. So, really, Benoit was the only worthwhile Revolution main event member.
Maybe it’s just me having been use to seeing those guys in mid-card level matches, but this was a Revolution that I didn’t want to be part of.
What are your memories of the Revolution? Would you have bought them all as main event wrestlers? Do you agree or disagree with my opinions? Let me know below!
Thanks for reading.
Bob Colling Of Wrestling Recaps
[spacer height=”20px”]
I think it could have worked if done correctly. All the guys were believable in the ring and could get any match over. Shane not as much as the others but he could talk better than the other 3. It was a good blend of talent that definitely could have worked. All 4 guys didn’t need to be main eventers. Benoit could have been the main event guy, Shane the semi-main, then Malenko and Saturn mid-card and they would have a spot in the whole show. It wouldn’t have been any different than what they did with DX in the WWF. Hunter was the top guy, Pac was in semi-main, then you had the Outlaws in the mid-card.
I really like the combination of wrestlers because you get a lot of different personalities and styles that could work with anyone on the roster. It’s a shame they didn’t get a longer run to see if they could have made it work. Just another one of those things that WCW missed out on.
The problem with this group was the leader always needs to be the best talker and best wrestler. Shane being the best talker but Benoit being the better wrestler makes the group fail from the start. Shane had plenty of memorable matches in ECW (you can read about many of them in my OMG ECW Reviews right here on CMax!!!) and was head and shoulders above Saturn, way above Malenko when factoring in complete package (Malenko obviously better in the ring but in no other way). Benoit is really the only one better out of the group in my opinion. His wrestling outshines Shane’s in such a manor that the lack of charisma doesn’t come into play.
I like the comparisons made in regards to other factions not requiring all main eventers in their group. In fact, if EVERYONE was a main eventer, there’s be some issues from the start. DX is a good point, because not only was Billy Gunn a mediocre wrestler at best, he couldn’t really talk all that great either, and he succeeded. I think as a unit, this team could have flourished in semi-main events, but I agree with the writer Bob here, and basically everyone else who responded, that certain guys lacked certain things needed to really be a stellar main event group. I think this group could have went on a while, with Benoit eventually breaking free as the main event babyface against a bunch of heel Revolution members who now resent him because he became “bigger than the group”. But now I’m just retro booking.
I like the idea with Benoit. Given a chance to run over time the break up would have been a good angel. Give Douglas the US title before building to the break up have Benoit grab that belt from him afterwards on his way to the World Title. You asked the question of if they could have been a main event stable. I’m going to say maybe….Looking at the PPV main event picture during the Revolutions run we have Nash vs. Hogan, Sting vs Hogan and Goldberg vs. Sting. Could Douglas hang with those guys as the leader of the group? I’d say yes. That’s not to say he is on their level by any means cause he’s not but in 1999 Hogan, Nash and Sting were all getting pretty stale and it was time to throw in some new talent. Douglas was good enough on the mic and in the ring to hang near those guys. I don’t think he should have ever came out on top of those guys, although I would have liked that as a Douglas fan. This could then lead way to Benoit rising up and taking the title as a face on his one when Douglas couldn’t do it with the backing of his group.